Bipolar Brain Imaging
This picture below shows a significant reduction in grey matter volume. It comes from a study of patients with bipolar disorder. It shows grey matter shrinking prefrontal and temporal regions of the brain. British researchers confirmed in 2007:
They found people with bipolar disorder suffer from an accelerated shrinking of their brain. Imaging studies carried out four years apart showed loss of brain tissue in the areas controlling memory, face recognition and co-ordination. Don’t panic over your bipolar brain…
I know the picture and research above are alarming!
However, just as bipolar can destroy grey matter, lithium re-grows it:
Just four weeks of treatment with lithium increases gray matter volume in the human brain, according to a study by Wayne State University School of Medicine on the bipolar brain. There are many ways people with bipolar disorder can improve their mental and physical health and nourish the bipolar brain.
Bipolar brain images
What else can bipolar brain images tell us? More and more, research is suggesting that our brain circuits may play just as big a role as our brain chemistry in predisposing some of us to bipolar disorder.
Studies show that bipolar people have different functioning in certain areas of the brain when compared to the population at large. In particular the limbic system shows consistent differences. The limbic system includes:
– the amygdala
– the hippocampus
– the cingulate gyrus.
It is the limbic system that controls emotion, motivation, memory and fear – the classic maladaptions of manic depressives. It may be that a major contributor to the disease is a failure in the way these areas of the brain communicate. In fact, over 25 studies show neurological abnormalities! These abnormalities often include things like loss of volume or loss of plasticity in the major pathways.
“Mental illnesses are brain diseases. Based on biomedical research, there is absolutely no justification for separating out mental disorders from other serious brain disorders. They are brain diseases just as a stroke or a brain tumor is a brain disease.” (Steven Hyman, director of the National Institute of Mental Health.)
However, polls and surveys show that around two-thirds of the population still don’t know that mental illnesses have physiological causes! (For example, I have a friend with cerebral palsy who has been known to kick some of us in the head when she has spasms. Of course nobody blames her or takes this personally. I once lost my temper amongst this same group of people and said a curse word. I was badly manic, off medication and having a full blown episode. My apologies were never accepted and I received hate mail accusing me of trying to manipulate people be pretending to have mental health issues. It doesn’t make me wish I had CP instead, or make me less ashamed of my behavior, or anxious to somehow make amends, but I do see a double standard and a certain amount of ignorance at play.)
Three Bipolar Brains
Three powerful bipolar brain images follow:
Lori Altshuler, director of the UCLA Mood Disorders Research Program, found that the amygdala seems to be significantly enlarged in patients with bipolar illness, along with enlarged ventricles. (Image © UCLA.)
From left: view of a normal brain; patient with bipolar disorder has enlarged ventricles; bright white spots of hyper-intensity associated with bipolar illness.
The next image is a structural MRI with functional MRI data superimposed. It shows that the left amygdala, a fear hub, and related structures, activated more in youth with the disorder than in healthy youth. (Credit: Source: NIMH Mood and Anxiety Disorders Program)
The left amygdala and related structures (yellow area where lines intersect) are part of an emotion-regulating brain circuit where children with bipolar disorder showed greater activation than controls when rating their fear of neutral faces.
Next, we see how brain SPECT imaging can illustrate clear differences between healthy and disordered brains. (Brain Matters Imaging Centers © 2007)
As the accompanying article explains, Brain SPECT Imaging provides: “graphic evidence that Bipolar Disorder is a biological problem that can be effectively treated as such.”
HOWEVER, IT IS IMPORTANT TO REMEMBER IT IS STILL EARLY DAYS. THE MEDICAL COMMUNITY DOES NOT ACCEPT BRAIN IMAGING AS RELIABLE FOR DIAGNOSIS OF BIPOLAR, ADHD OR OTHER RELATED CONDITIONS.
Even established experts using SPECT and related technologies still use patient histories and self-tests as a diagnostic foundation.
Future of bipolar brain imaging
Why is it that these brain imaging techniques, which have already taught us so much, cannot be used to diagnose bipolar?
There are two main reasons:
- The studies have shown statistically significant amounts of people with mood disorders show certain brain abnormalities. However, although there there is a statistical pattern, there is still some overlap between people with mood disorders and the general population. This means that brain imaging cannot conclusively determine whether someone has a mood disorder.
- The brain abnormalities found so far are non-specific and can also show up on people with quite different disorders, for example people with psychiatric disorders such as schizophrenia.
“Through functional brain imaging studies, affective circuits have been identified that mediate manic-depressive illness. Key areas inclide the amygdala and related limbic structures, and regions of the basal ganglia.” Goodwin and Jamison
However, given the problems with diagnosing bipolar, and especially the recent controversy over accurately identifying childhood bipolar disorder it is important that research continue.